Since When is Following the Rules Discrimination?
Today’s New York Times has the following report:
Toys “R” Us yesterday reversed its decision and awarded a $25,000 savings bond to a baby born on New Year’s Day to parents who are not legal United States residents.
The company, and its Babies “R” Us division, said it was giving away not one but three prizes in the contest for the first baby born in 2007, including one to Yuki Lin, who arrived at midnight at New York Downtown Hospital in Manhattan.
Yuki had tied with two others: Yadira Esmeralda, born at Southside Hospital in Bay Shore, on Long Island; and Jayden Swain of Gainesville, Ga. Yuki was chosen the winner by a drawing from all three names, then was disqualified because the rules excluded babies whose mothers are not legal residents. The prize was then awarded to Jayden.
Now all three babies will get $25,000 bonds. The original decision was reported in The World Journal, a Chinese-language newspaper.
The New York Times reported on the controversy yesterday. Later in the day, the company released a statement apologizing for the tumult.
“We love all babies,” the statement said. “We deeply regret that this sweepstakes became a point of controversy. As a result, we have decided to award all three babies in the grand prize pool a $25,000 savings bond.”
Yuki’s parents — Han Lin and Yan Zhu Liu, both 22-year-old restaurant workers — declined to be interviewed. But Albert H. Wang, a corporate lawyer who had mounted an e-mail campaign on the couple’s behalf, said that they were happy, adding, “I think justice has been done.”
Some people were concerned that the parents’ status had been exposed, he said. “But the safest place is actually the eye of the storm,” Mr. Wang said, “and any politician who says we should deport the parents, it would be the end of their political career.”
Here’s what I don’t understand; the rules clearly stated that the mother had to be a legal resident - I believe that most contest rules usually state that - how does the fact that she wasn’t a legal resident and therefore wasn’t within the rules of the contest equate with discrimination? A longer version of this article in the Times from the day before states the following:
Some Chinese-American advocates said the company’s decision smacked of second-class citizenship.
”People are just pretty much outraged,” said John Wang, president of the New York-based Asian American Business Development Center.
Albert Wang, an attorney, who launched the e-mail campaign said ”She was deprived of $25,000 intended to be used for her college education because of who her parents are,” he said.
“second-class citizenship”?? “deprived of $25,000″??? What the hell? Maybe I don’t understand this because I’m a white guy but I was always taught that you follow the rules unless the rules are patently unfair. I don’t think this is the case here. I think that the rules were broken for this couple because they’re a member of a minority group. If this woman would have been from Croatia or Russia I don’t think she would have gotten money.
Now I’m not an anti-imigration person. I firmly believe we need some sort of guest worker status because I believe that much of the work done by immigrants, like this girl’s parents, is work that most Americans don’t want to do. I also believe that anyone who wants to work hard and follow the rules deserves a chance at a better life. What I don’t believe in is changing the rules for a person or group of people simply because of their race. I’m sure this lawyer feels pretty proud of himself. He bullied a big company into breaking the rules with cries of racism. If he felt so strongly about this and so badly for the parents, why didn’t he write them a check? Every time someone trots out claims of racism and asks for special consideration because of the color of their skin it sets things back a little bit. There may have been a time when that was necessary for certain groups but I think it’s becoming a crutch for some and a cudgel for others.
In
Democrats made a strong showing in
Even though I suspect that the results of this election may be mired in legal battles for weeks - with all the talk over the last couple of days about attempts to keep voters away from the polls I thought I’d post a few bits of info that I think might be helpful. Here’s a few steps to take to make sure you get to exercise your legal right to vote: